Wish I was a little bit taller...
I'm biased in two places on this one...first, the W.
Sox are playing the
Tigs. Second, I tend to side with umpires/referees on most things (despite a seething problem with authority, just ask those three cops I got fired in Jackson, Mich...booyah.)
The issue has long been Ozzie
Guillen running his mouth about pretty much anything. Add to this, the official "correct" call percentage in
MLB hovers at around 95 percent as judged by the video monitoring system the league installed several years back, according to what the
MLB veep said at the camp.
So that leaves you with 1 out of 20 pitches being called either a ball or a strike when "by-the-book" it is actually the opposite. (for an amateur, this climbs to well around 6 out of 20) The point is, every game sees more than 10 pitches that are technically called improperly. The best you can do as an Ump is to make sure you're calling the same zone no matter which team is batting. And that's usually what the league, the managers and -- to a lesser extent -- the players hold the Umpires to.

The White
Sox are off to a very poor start with Umpires this year with
Ozzie loudly getting into a tiff with
Phil Cuzzi (10) the other day, saying he calls strikes against the
Sox because
Cuzzi doesn't like him.
Ehh.
But the attitude pervades the organization. Today, Jim
Thome was tossed by Home Plate Ump James
Hoye (a rookie-
ish fellow) for arguing balls and strikes. It happened after Thome sat on a strike out pitch that ate full plate and fronted at the tips of his generously tall knees (the southern border of the strike zone is defined the hollow of the knee, or the top of your shin really). He lost it. The announcers (the hot-and-cold combo of “Hawk”
Harrelson and former OF Darrin Jackson) spent the rest of the game complaining about the call, the zone and how the
Sox "had the bat taken out of their hands." By the end, the Sox gabbers suggested the Tigers had a different zone (
Magglio and Inge both suffered borderline calls late) and that "a strike for us is pretty much anything that hits the glove of Pudge Rodriguez." On and on it went.
The point is...one pitch at one at-bat is not worth this amount of anger. For 100+ years, the league has accepted this -- hence, the reason you get tossed for arguing balls and strikes. If this was allowed, the games would never end. And worrying about it these days with the Umps under video grading is tantamount to giving yourself a complex -- always a no-no for a hitter, pitcher or team.
But it's not just baseball. Those that complain usually only serve to get inside their own heads (Kobe, Mark Cuban,
Guillen) and truly lose any sympathy from the Umpire/Referee crews. It seems the
Sox are being consumed by this attitude from the top already. I know this much, the Tigers liked seeing
Thome leave the game more than any of the Umpires did.
Huddy Extra: If you got to see it, you can really see the difference in an experienced salt like
Cuzzi taking flak and a young ump like
Hoye. With the old guys, the eyes are bored, the bodies are firm, posture perfect...great body language. With
Hoye, his eyes were bright and he had slightly nervous body language. It's subtle, but it's there. When
Ted Barrett (65) -- who happened to by on 3rd in this game -- was screaming in my face, playing an
irate manager after I blew a call, I had the benefit of sunglasses to hide my nonverbal expression...which was certainly screaming "help" thanks to Barrett's generous height of at least 6' 4" with a build and bark to match.
Hoye had no such protection, but fortunately had the full support of his crew in case he was getting nervous.
I saw a clip of the other Umpires in the crew before the game giving
Hoye a fist bump on the chest to pump him up before the game. So he must be a real newbie, though I saw he had been behind the plate before from some box scores. He handled himself well, I thought. And he kept his zone the same after the dust up from the normally staid
Thome.